Refutation of Bin Bayyah/Hamza Yusuf
Upon even more exam and study belonging to the record of container Bayyah, I realized that his or her records are incorrect and misleading in many ways:
The scholars did not are different in this particular matter whatever since there was ijmaa€? from the prohibition of congratulating non-Muslims to their breaks. This opinion is revealed by Ibn al-Qayyim as he explained, a€?Congratulating the non-Muslims within their traditions that belong simply to all of them was haram by viewpoint (on the students).a€? 16 thus, this ijmaa€? that was demonstrated are not broken under any scenario as well as famous among the many students of fiqh and usul. As well as the ones declare that ijmaa€? was not set up in this particular problems, then this problem of evidence consist upon them to develop his or her record. Neither trash Bayyah nor any of the many modern day scholars giving fatwa of permissibility demonstrate anything that would nullify the account of ijmaa€? by Ibn al-Qayyim.
In reality, there are just two suggestions in madhhab of Imam Ahmad, haram and makruh, and not three as Bin Bayyah specified. Additionally, the perspective of the two thought in the madhhab wasn’t in regards to congratulating kuffar on their own festivals, but alternatively it has been relating to congratulating them on non-religious pleased affair, as Ibn al-Qayyim mentions. Additionally, al-Mardawi claims, a€?The 2nd thoughts would be that it is not necessarily forbidden but disliked as described inside the e-books of Ria€?ayah and al-Hawiyayn inside chapter of janaa€™iz.a€? 17 Al-Mardawi keeps going to estimate the illustration of the Prophet i·? browsing sick Jewish girl in order that he might acknowledge Islam. Thus, it is typically mentioned definitely your framework of makruh wasn’t in relation to congratulating non-Muslims within their fests and breaks but using regard to guest these people as soon as are generally unwell or general hello on non-religious parties.
Pertaining to Ibn Taymiyyah seeking the opinion of permissibility in congratulating non-Muslims for their fests, this is often inaccurate plus incorrect as al-Mardawi says the context which Ibn Taymiyyah pick this a€?permissibilitya€™ by claiming: a€?It (visiting their unwell) is definitely permissible for a precise maslahah (overall close) like the want that they’re going to accept Islam. This viewpoint got liked by Ibn Taymiyyah.a€? 18 also, how does it is possible for Ibn Taymiyyah to get the advice of permissibility when he obviously and unequivocally happens to be on the opinion that congratulating and participating in these fests, it does not matter they being religious or non-religious, is entirely prohibited? 19 Additionally, for trash Bayyah to convey that Ibn Taymiyyaha€™s a€?confirmeda€™ advice is the fact of permissibility is 
incredibly unreliable, because their a€?confirmeda€™ viewpoint is exactly what is actually relayed by him in his greatest masterpiece, Iqtidaa€™ al-Sirat al-Mustaqim fi Mukhalafati Ashab al-Jaa??im, which can be absolutely and solely dedicated to no congratulating and participating for the celebrations of non-Muslims.
Suhaib Webb
The type of which allowed congratulating non-Muslims within their celebrations is definitely Suhaib Webb. On December 26, 2012 he posted on his or her private facebook or myspace web page what can consider a justification for greeting non-Muslims on xmas and New Yeara€™s. The man says:
The American Fatwa Council; contains 20 of worlda€™s perfect Muslim Jurists, stated that it really is permissible to welcome people on nowadays (swap gifts even) if it will not need approving any creedal differences when considering all of us, or open bad (consuming alcohol and so forth). To put it differently, an easy happier holiday breaks is absolutely not a sin or planning to take that person away Islam. Truly documented with authentic stores that Ali (ra) renowned the Persian New Year, even consuming ice cream with Imam Abu Hanifaa€™s family member. Some of the fatwa cited by honest folks are rooted in an age of kingdom and battle (the crusades) or a cultural facts that will not fit mine when you look at the West. Above all, people should inquire individuals who need terms like a€?harama€? a€?kufura€? a€?Halala€? and a€?encourageda€? regarding their religious practise. Yelling and over taken emotionalism don’t equivalent training and scholarship. Allah realizes best. (Webb, 2012).
